Which version of melodyne do you have? I was led to believe that if you have melodyne editor 1.x then
the melodyne installed with Sonar x3 (that is melodyne 2 basic but not melodyne editor) could mess you up.
I went ahead and upgraded to melodyne editor 2 (haven't installed) and then I upgraded to Sonar x3 (haven't installed it either).
 

JohnoL
I went ahead and upgraded to melodyne 2 (haven't installed) and then I upgraded to Sonar x3 (haven't installed it either).

So far you are the ultimate slacker.
 
Well done.

bapu

JohnoL
I went ahead and upgraded to melodyne 2 (haven't installed) and then I upgraded to Sonar x3 (haven't installed it either).

So far you are the ultimate slacker.
 
Well done.

I did get my taxes done a couple of weeks ago.

JohnoL

bapu

JohnoL
I went ahead and upgraded to melodyne 2 (haven't installed) and then I upgraded to Sonar x3 (haven't installed it either).

So far you are the ultimate slacker.
 
Well done.

I did get my taxes done a couple of weeks ago.

Yeah, but for what year?  2003? 

JohnoL
Which version of melodyne do you have? I was led to believe that if you have melodyne editor 1.x then
the melodyne installed with Sonar x3 (that is melodyne 2 basic but not melodyne editor) could mess you up.
I went ahead and upgraded to melodyne editor 2 (haven't installed) and then I upgraded to Sonar x3 (haven't installed it either).
 

no, I have the latest version, whatever that is.

JohnoL

bapu

JohnoL
I went ahead and upgraded to melodyne 2 (haven't installed) and then I upgraded to Sonar x3 (haven't installed it either).

So far you are the ultimate slacker.
 
Well done.

I did get my taxes done a couple of weeks ago.

you're ahead of me!!!

Hey Beagle,
Besides the new toys that have already been mentioned, X3 performs smoother on my system than X2.  I like the comping better and I use Melodyne all the time for edited audio in many ways as well as converting audio to midi. 
I also really like the fly-out EQ.  Addictive Drums was fun to play with but I still rely on SD 2.
 

Beagle

JohnoL
Which version of melodyne do you have? I was led to believe that if you have melodyne editor 1.x then
the melodyne installed with Sonar x3 (that is melodyne 2 basic but not melodyne editor) could mess you up.
I went ahead and upgraded to melodyne editor 2 (haven't installed) and then I upgraded to Sonar x3 (haven't installed it either).
 

no, I have the latest version, whatever that is.

I was told by Melodyne Support that after I upgraded to Melodyne Editor 2 that I should use that (Editor 2) reg/serial #
when the Sonar X3 upgrade asked for the melodyne serial and not the one from the Sonar upgrade. If you do get SonarX3 you might research that just to make sure.

Thanks Jimmy.
 
"better comping" so far is the only thing that has really kept me considering it.  and that's very relative.
 
if they had fixed the drum map or something useful like that I probably wouldn't have had to consider it.
 
as it is, time is running out for my decision...