Karyn
How is chopping up a clip any more destructive than adding automated clip gain or a gate?
The multiple clips you end up with when you chop one up are all just links to the same original audio file (take) on disk. If you want back what you "deleted" just grab the edge of the clip and drag it out.
Also, it doesn't save any disk space by deleting silence in this manner because the underlying audio file remains unchanged. You'd have to separately bounce each clip to a new file and then delete the original audio file.
using the 'ALT' tab and dragging the cursor across multiple tracks at once to take out entire sections of 'blank' space is so much easier then automating all of those areas.
plus
depending on how much volume automation i'm going to do,
sometimes putting in the envelope FIRST, then doing the deleting of unnecessary audio, creates new nodes for the volume automation on each section of audio that is left, which IF you plan on doing a lot of volume rides, makes it easier to set up.
then, you just grab the middle of that section of automation envelope, and either lift or drop, it's super quick and efficient.
for me.
after my 'deletions' are all done, i simply 'select all', and hit 'apply trimming'.
a lot of times, i can quickly go thru an entire mix, deleting (trimming) everywhere i need to,
and then go zoom in and focus on trouble areas, whereas all i have to do then, is grab the edge of the audio, and pull it exactly where i need to for the edit.
then, i can put volume envelopes across the entire individual tracks, and do typical node points and rides.
it works either way.
i often use volume automation instead of compression, and i do a lot of edits.
to my ears, it sounds better.