I think the VRM box is incredibly useful. First of all, if you're completely limited to headphones then it's going to improve your mix's translatability immensely. But even if you're not, the box gives you a number of different listening environments to check your mix against. This is 100% more convenient than burning mixes to CD's and taking them into your car, over to your friend's house etc. It doesn't not matter whether or not the simulations are particularly "realistic" version of the listening environments and speakers they claim to be. What matters is that when you listen to a good mix through the VRM box, it translates well to all of the simulations. By that I mean the instruments are well balanced against each other whether you set the VRM to KRK's, Adams, Auratones, laptop speakers, TV speakers or 90's Hi-fi (to list some of the VRM presets). Nothing sticks out too much, the bass part is audible on small tinny speakers, instrument separation is good etc. I've listened to a lot of classic mixes through the VRM box, and they work through every preset. A tinny TV speaker isn't going to give you a great listening experience but a good mix will project the essentials of the music through it in a balance that communicates the soul and essence of the track. A great song that's mixed well will sound great even when played on a cheap AM radio.
I think where a lot of people go wrong with the VRM box is in expecting to be able to do all of their mixing through it. Wrong! I believe the correct way to use the VRM box is to mix through whatever speakers you have (whether that be monitors in a treated room, monitors with ARC or a good pair of headphones) and to use the box frequently to CHECK YOUR MIX DECISIONS through a few of the simulations to get an idea of any problem areas that need tweaking. For example you might find that your bass and kick parts are completely inaudible through the laptop speaker preset, or that the vocal jumps out too far on the Auratones. It's a balancing act of course. You're finding EQ and compression settings that work in many listening situations.
It seems to me that the more listening environments you have at hand to check your mix through, the better.
Any discussion about mixing through headphones is incomplete without the usual warning about keeping levels low. This is especially true in the case of earbuds, which can cause a lot more damage than over the ear cans due to the proximity of the sound source to your eardrum. It's important to keep the levels lower than you would ordinarily listen to, because you're going to be wearing those cans for a lot longer on a mixing project than you would if you were just listening in a recreational context. 5-6 hour sessions are not uncommon, and that's an awfully long time to wear headphones. If I'm working with headphones I stop for a break every 15-20 minutes. Tear 'em off and do something else for 5 minutes. And make sure you're getting enough magnesium, because a deficiency will leave your ears more vulnerable to noise damage.