Greetings Jeff, and thank you for your thoughts.
I shall check out Melodyne.
As for the "figuring it out", I know what you're saying, that it's not that hard. Except when it is, of course!
As a further explanation of my personal difficulty, here's an example, and the impetus for my thread today: About an hour ago I heard a fantastic song on somebody's website. It's a dance song. The site and the song are long gone now. I could tell that the predominant "color" was minor. That was
all I could come up with.
I cannot tell if it was C minor, G minor, A minor, or ANYTHING ELSE-minor. I also could not tell if it had any diminishments, dominants, susses, fifths, sevenths, ninths, or thirteenths. This is really getting me down just writing this.
I've got a handle on major and minor and that's the limit of my current skill level. I am in my 40's, have been listening to music all my life and playing it for a good portion of that,
so this frustrates me. We were not taught "recognition skills" in school band, after-school guitar lessons, or before-school jazz band practice.
We were only taught to read and play, read and play, like little robots. I played a single-note instrument for much of my youth, so "comprehensive chord recognition" didn't even happen by accident because I wasn't exposed to if often enough (i.e., see chord on page, hear it as I play or as band plays). For that, I feel that my music education was not complete or comprehensive.
I am not tone-deaf by any means. I can match pitches. Play a C in my range and I can sing it. I can find it on a keyboard, guitar, or horn. But play a Bb and ask me what it is without letting me hunt-and-peck, and I'll have no damned idea. Play a C-major chord, and I can tell you it's a major chord. Play a G-minor. I could tell you it's a minor, but no way could I tell you it was G-minor with the D on the bottom...
Anyway, that's the background on this. And I think it's the sole reason for the migrane headache I now have.
But thank you for trying to help; I'll check out Melodyne.