I really didn't expect to get this much feedback. I started out intending for this to be of a more technical nature...but it seems that some of you must have had situations similar to mine in some fashion or other.
Yes...a lot of this is because he is one of my oldest friends, and the recordings we have done together over the years have helped me through some very tough times. Actually..the Avatar for my profile is (my main) guitar that he built for me from scratch when my father passed away about 5 years ago.
And though I don't care for his drum machine or lack of real concern regarding sound quality...he gets a surprisingly good guitar tone on "tape". I actually asked him once about the specifics..(mic placement, etc)...his answer..."I don't know...I just stick the mic in front of the amp, turn it way up and I play". Go figure...
Sidroe was correct...I was getting 2 track "mixes" to add my parts to (mp3's no less). After discussing this with him he has conceded to sending me the bundle files. So...that may help.
I'm probably not going to get into it with him (Good point Mixmkr)...after all...maybe I'm taking it too seriously. If the stuff I do with him sounds a little hokey...so what. I mean, we're doing it for fun, not to make money. Hell, we haven't played in the same room (or even the same state) in years. If we come up with something special, then I would put the hammer down and push for doing it properly. But until then...I should probably lighten up. He's not going to change, and neither am I.
And yes, Jay Tee you picked up properly on the 4 variables. Hopefully the bundle files will alleviate at least a couple of them. Oh...and he says he will make sure to sync the machine with cakewalk. One thing...I may have misspoken in an earlier post. I had thought he sent me the midi drum files at one time...but he claims his drum machine only has a MIDI in and no MIDI out....so I'm not sure what I'm remembering.
I really can't tell you how helpful this has been. Even though this thread has gone way off the "official" topic.
Oh and Mettalus...I was a Fostex X-15 guy. ;)
Thanks again, folks.