sharke
...like most plugs, it's quite possible to dial in settings that make it sound worse, and I have no doubt that RBass is the same.
When trying out any new plugin, I always start with two assumptions: a) if it sounds bad, I'm probably not doing it right, and b) it's probably more capable than first impressions might indicate.
But RBass only has two controls, not counting the output volume fader. The number of ways one might screw it up are few. I honestly think I pretty much exhausted all the possible combinations in the first ten minutes.
I dropped RBass into at least a dozen projects. These were all finished songs where the bass had already been tweaked and massaged, so I started each test by bypassing all effects. I first listened to the bass track both in solo and in context with no processing, to get the original sound in my head. I then compared with RBass applied, and then with the original effects restored. In each case, I monitored with SPAN at the bottom of the fx bin in order to see what was happening with the spectrum as well as to aid in volume matching. I listened with main monitors and then with two different headphones.
I repeated this test with many projects, although I admit they were all my own projects and therefore had some general commonality. I did not try it on, for example, any metal tunes or hip-hop. But within the constrained test set, there was not a single instance where RBass made the bass track sound better. In every case it took on a muffled, plastic tone, lost transients and lost its place in the mix. In every case the volume rose, requiring about a 6dB reduction to match volume with the original.
On a couple projects, I also compared RBass to my most-used bass-warping tools: FabFilter Saturn, Voxengo LF Max Punch, Voxengo Boogex, and plain ol' compression and EQ.
Granted, this is not an apples-to-apples comparison. Saturn gives you a ton of possibilities, including multi-band envelope shaping and dynamics expansion. Boogex is a distortion plugin with EQ and dynamics control. LF Max Punch probably comes closest to RBass, but has far more options. The justification for comparing these to RBass is that I use them all for bass treatment. In every case, RBass came in a distant fifth runner-up.
I'll keep it around on the chance that someday the right track will come along that suits RBass. But as far as I can tell at this time, RBass is quite useless to me. If you disagree, I'd love to hear a before-and-after comparison clip that illustrates a marked improvement with RBass.