2013/10/07 22:31:44
marcus3
Okay here my problem and I don't understand. I've been playing piano sense 10th grade started classical last year and already composing. 
I can sight read, play and slowly composing. 
I heard I can go ask for the test but when I look it up says I've got go for 6-12 years 6 for education 6 for performing.
But I've got lot the education "taught lot myself" and understand lot it I've also started performing some.
 
So could I ask for the test or what?
Also is Ear training require I have problem with my left ear with hearing. I have always struggle playing by ear.
 
Thanks
Marcus 
2013/10/07 22:32:57
backwoods
Go thru the grades. 
2013/10/08 01:18:22
Linear Phase
I can't think of anything more useless..   @ this point, you are better off trying to become a plumber.
 
 
but don't let that discourage you...
2013/10/08 06:53:44
Mystic38
Music, the only course where coming 5th in class is perfect
2013/10/08 07:50:08
Guitarhacker
if it's a case of take the test or not..... and there's nothing to lose by doing so... sure.... take the test.  It will show you where you actually are. 
 
A lot of times being self taught will miss tons of things that you would have learned had you taken the grades and completed them. If that is the case... you would then know your options and plan accordingly if you want a masters degree in music..... they normally just don't hand those things out to anyone.
 
However, there are thousands of musicians who never took a single lesson and have made a career out of music so the masters degree is not necessary, except for your personal satisfaction of having completed that course of study.
2013/10/08 08:37:26
Moshkiae
Guitarhacker
if it's a case of take the test or not..... and there's nothing to lose by doing so... sure.... take the test.  It will show you where you actually are. 
 ...


Compared to that scale only!
 
But your name might be Joe Schmoe, and you have a hot band, that makes good money and you are just about retired from so much money, and you really need to know that? And how many of those musicians are trying to climb that mountain barefoot only to find that all there is up there is a hot volcano that will eat you up, because you are not good enough!
 
I still think it's all relative, and that we're not machines that have to sound just like each other in the best socialist fashion there is!
2013/10/08 09:42:57
UbiquitousBubba
It might help to think of music as a fundamental part of who you are as a person rather than as a career.  Your vocation does not define you.  It pays you.  There's a difference.  Your artistry lies much deeper under the surface.  It changes how you think, how you see the world, and how you express yourself.  Your music career is not limited to a few moments in the spotlight.  It is lived out over the course of your entire life.  Musicians create music because they are musicians, not only for the money.  If no one was listening, we'd still play.  We are compelled to do so.
 
In my extremely humble opinion, you may want to spend some time thinking about what it is that really want.  It's one thing to say that you want to make a living as a musician.  It's another to define for yourself exactly what that means and then chart a course in that direction.  How flexible is this plan?  If life throws the unexpected at you (and it will), how will you adapt?  Some people say that you should hurl yourself into the unknown with no reservations and no backup plan.  Others tell you to protect yourself with alternatives and backup strategies.  The bottom line is that no one else can tell you what your decision should be.  We can only tell you what we chose when we encountered these questions.  There is no single path to take as a musician.  There is, on the other hand, the artistry, which will pulse through your soul for the rest of your life. 
2013/10/08 09:53:42
Moshkiae
UbiquitousBubba
It might help to think of music as a fundamental part of who you are as a person rather than as a career.  Your vocation does not define you.  It pays you.  There's a difference.  Your artistry lies much deeper under the surface.  It changes how you think, how you see the world, and how you express yourself.  Your music career is not limited to a few moments in the spotlight.  It is lived out over the course of your entire life.  Musicians create music because they are musicians, not only for the money.  If no one was listening, we'd still play.  We are compelled to do so.
 
...



Thank you ... just about what I said, except you were wayyyyyyy clearer than I was!
 
Very true and every word of it.
2013/10/08 11:28:33
craigb
Moshkiae
 
But your name might be Joe Schmoe, and you have a hot band, that makes good money and you are just about retired from so much money, and you really need to know that? And how many of those musicians are trying to climb that mountain barefoot only to find that all there is up there is a hot volcano that will eat you up, because you are not good enough!


Hi,
 
This is really just a hidden movie review of Joe and the Volcano isn't it?  
2013/10/09 00:06:37
marcus3
Thanks everyone and UbiquitousBubba good point. 
 
To clear things up I'm 24 I've been playing for 6 years this being my 6th. I do want to be composer and piano player.
I always told people I don't want to go college I'm having fun just playing and composing and that all I want do.
But people keep feeling my head with no you need to go college and as much I appreciate the art of music
when I'm writing I don't think of music theory rules. I use my ears and feelings and mind. 
 
But thanks for some insight it cleared things up for me. 

 
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account