Nasty DLA may actually be a better choice if you're specifically looking for a tape delay simulation.
Another inexpensive "creative" delay is Rob Papen's RP-Delay, which can do all sorts of wacky modulation and stuff. But as with Ubermod, getting any specific effect involves a lot of trial-and-error experimentation.
Of course, if you want the ultimate do-anything delay that would be FabFilter's Timeless 2. But it's way beyond anything most of us need for bread 'n butter delay effects.
Personally, I usually reach for the good ol' Sonitus Delay first for most tasks. If they'd just do a little work on it, fix some bugs, add some modulation, it could be on par with the best delays out there.