• Coffee House
  • Any opinions on Welsh's Synthesizer Cookbook?
2013/08/18 10:11:24
sharke
I figure there's someone here who has read it and I wouldn't mind another opinion to supplement the good reviews on Amazon before I splash the cash:
 
http://www.amazon.com/Welshs-Synthesizer-Cookbook-Analysis-Universal/dp/B000ERHA4S/sr=1-1/qid=1157381135/ref=pd_bbs_1/104-7167689-1467104?ie=UTF8&s=books
2013/08/18 12:14:56
bapu
I'd read it if it was synthesized down for dummies like me.
2013/08/18 13:16:00
craigb
Do the Bakers need a cookbook?
2013/08/18 15:22:10
Moshkiae
Hi,
 
If this is a beginner's guide to synthsizers, I would like to find one that is more helpful than the guides that show up in Computer Music (for example) that is missing steps and pictures, and the sequence of instructions doesn't make sense!
 
I do not think that most people actually KNOW how to play synthesizers ... they only use the "sounds" and then add some effects over it, and that is a waste of the overall design of a synthesizer and its possibilities.
 
I've been trying for 2 years, here in Vancouver/Portland to find someone that can give me a few lessons, and no one knows synthesizers and Beacock Music, told me straight out, stop fooling around with those dinosaurs, as no one can do anything on them or how to make them work.
I really wanted to learn how to use the Sequencer, and some other tricks ... but no one knows, and Craig is not interested in getting paid for a couple of hours!
2013/08/18 15:23:44
Moshkiae
craigb
Do the Bakers need a cookbook?




Yes, to get started. Baking and Cooking is all about the PROCEDURE, not the recipe!
 
Once you know the basis and procedure, the rest is easy!
 
Same for you with your music!
2013/08/18 16:12:49
The Maillard Reaction
 
Best Mosh post evah!!!
2013/08/18 16:33:19
dmbaer
The book is not that expensive and definitely worth the money, IMO.  There are three parts: intro to subtractive synthesis, sound analysis, and recipes.  By sound analysis, I mean he spends a lot of time explaining how to figure out what wave types (saw, square, etc.) and in what combinations you need to come up with a synthetic version of an acoustic sound.  The second section is dry and heavy going, but the book is worth it just for the first and third.
 
I spent some time "cooking" many of the recipes on DIVA.  I first did some calibrations of envelope parameters (tedious, but necessary).  That's straightforward using SONAR.  I did not use Welsh's recommended way of getting filter cutoffs.  A much easier way is to set the filter resonance all the way up, set the filter at the position you want to measure, play a bunch of adjacent notes low on the KB (playing through a saw wave), and look at the result in Span.  The cutoff jumps right out at you, or at least until your cutoff settings dip below maybe 500Hz.
 
Some of the cooked recipes are terrific sounding and some are kind of lame.  The pads and leads are nothing to get excited about IMO.  The acoustic synthetic sounds are a mixed bag, but some of them are *very* good indeed.  Of course, the same recipes on a different synth may be a whole different thing.
 
By the way, I posted the DIVA patch library for free download, if there are any DIVA owners out there interested.
2013/08/18 17:11:00
bapu
mike_mccue
 
Best Mosh post evah!!!


Best McQ Post praising "Best Mosh Post EVAH" EVAH!!!
2013/08/18 17:43:05
The Maillard Reaction
Well Done. ;-)
2013/08/18 19:42:58
sharke
Well that's good enough for me - ordered. 
 
I quite enjoyed watching this old synth video tutorial recently - it's Dean Friedman, done in the 80's and ridiculously cheesy, but great all the same. Starts from the very beginning. In 3 parts on YouTube. 
 

 
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account