SquireBum
I used Overture 5 to successfully transcribe three Piano pieces. Two of them used real-time MIDI recording and the Garritan ARIA VST, followed by clean-up in the data editor. The third transcription used step-entry with the built-in GM piano.
While learning and testing the software, I have experienced an occasional "is Shutting down" crash, but some of it could be attributed to me clicking somewhere that the program didn't expect. The software is definitely not bug free, but I really like the real-time recording and piano roll style editing. I would definitely recommend using the Auto-Save feature, which was enabled and set to every minute by default on my system.
After working with Overture for a few days, I opened Notion 6 and made several attempts at real-time recording with very poor results.
-- Ron
Yeah, I was impressed with all of the design and interface features of Overture, and how they were implemented. It is, hands down, the fastest and easiest notation software I've ever used when it comes to note entry and overall score creation (and I've used most of them, including Sibelius, Finale, etc). Don has great ideas in regards to intuitive interface and workflow. I
really wish it was stable and I could work with it.
But that whole "Overture 5 is shutting down" routine was really getting to me. Nothing worse than being in the middle of a great creative moment, and suddenly your software is crashing to the desktop and you have to reopen it and pick up where you left off. To its credit, Overture 5 starts right up again, and thanks to the autosave you've usually lost only a minute or two of work. But still...
And to be honest, you clicking somewhere the program didn't expect is hardly a good reason for it to crash. That, to my mind, is the very definition of a bug. And for me it makes Overture very frustrating to use -- especially because I think the program has a ton of potential. It's a great design.
Fortunately in my case, step recording via midi interface is my preferred notation input method, and I find Notion very good that. One major detail I do prefer about Notion vs Overture: in Notion, when you hover over a note you want to apply a marking or notation element to, the entire note area is a target, making it easier and faster to apply those markings. With Overture, you have to be really precise - if you want to apply staccato markings to a note, you need to put your cursor crosshairs right in the note head, otherwise the marking could be applied to the space around the note - which does nothing and looks strange. This makes for finicky work and takes more time. Notion identifies the note you want to use the moment your mouse pointer is anywhere near it, and I find it
way easier and faster to apply markings or ornamentations that way.
I also really like that Notion is setup right out of the box with decent sounding instruments with multiple articulations. This actually caught me off guard the first time: I applied a pizzicato marking to a contrabass line I was working on, and on playback, the bass notes were suddenly playing pizz samples - automatically.