peter434
Hi cryophonik
There was a misunderstanding about the term "worth"; I'm French and many times, Google traduction does not give the perfect translation.
By "worth", I didn't think about the financial aspect but about the "plus" tool value that tiers plugin could deliver in comparison with the Sonar plugins arsenal, which is growing in number as new sonar versions are succeeding...
I was considering buying the Vertigo at it was 60% off, but cannot compare it with the internal plugs of Sonar because : 1) I still have not Sonar, will receive it in some days and 2) the Brainworx Christmas discount sale for each plug is only 1/2 days and it's too short...
So, I just wanted to know if there was a genuine qualitative big difference or if we can have identical sonic results with some internal plugins, (even if I know there are subtle nuances which are hard to compare depending of various factors...)
Sorry again for the misunderstanding.
Pierre
Hi Pierre - no problem!
I understand what you're asking now and it's definitely a reasonable question. The Plugin Alliance plugins are held in high regard among serious producers/musicians, but I've only had hands-on experience with a few of them, so maybe someone else here can chime in with their opinions. Many of their plugins fill niches that other developers haven't really attempted to fill. For example, the Elysia Alpha Compressor that was on sale a few days ago is a highly touted mastering compressor with some mid/side features and filtering that you won't find in any of Sonar's plugins. But, I think it's safe to say that, generally speaking, most of us (esp. us hobbyists) don't need those features and probably have less appreciation for the differences in sonic quality that it would offer over other compressors. To me, it's definitely not worth $299, but I definitely considered it at $119. Then, rationality got in the way and I started to realize that it would probably end up being just another good deal added to my already large pile of compressor plugins (far more than I need or even use), so I let it pass. That said, I will be buying the Mpressor when it goes on sale because it has some unique tricks up its sleeve and because it's one that I've wanted for a long time, but could never justify the price tag.
One plugin that I did buy was the SPL Transient Designer, which I've wanted for a long time. I own several other transient designers (e.g., Sonar's bundled one, Sonnox TransMod, Flux Bittersweet), but IMO the SPL version sounds the best and is the most effective for shaping transients of all the transient designers I've owned/demoed. To me, it's probably worth the $199 normal price, but I just remained patient and got it for $89, which was a no-brainer for me. That said, Sonar's bundled transient designer is no slouch and compares quite favorably to the more expensive SPL and Sonnox versions. But, as I mentioned above, I can't use Sonar's version in my other hosts, so I tend to favor my third-party versions.