The BBE sonic maximiser has been around for *years*. Whether or not you believe in the *magic* of the *secret process* is up to you - but people still use these type of plugs on a snare drum or even a "dead" bass guitar for example. Can you do the same thing with EQ? Probably - but it's easier with a BBE plug. Just turn it on - et voila!
I actually got these plugs cheap because I had the old Cakewalk BBE plugin from *years ago*. Now the ver 3 upgrade is $29 - so it's not a big deal.
I'd say it's good to have in the armory, and you'd definitely use these things sparingly.
If you don't believe in the *magic* - I'd say just forget it and move on. it's not worth arguing about, and definitely not worth wasting time analysing waveforms etc etc
Just my £0.02 (worth $0.03)