Andrew Rossa [Cakewalk]
I think our approach to development would be the same for lifetime updates as it would for membership. The difference is there is no cut off for lifetime updates. We'll still deliver new features for SONAR, in fact we have some cool ones planned. We say core features to distinguish between features that are core to the program and other products we develop at Cakewalk. For example. we develop Z3TA+ 2 and that's not included in SONAR. Any future products including effects and plugins may not be included in SONAR (like Rapture Pro, Expansion Packs). And this certainly will allow us to focus on core improvements and enhancements, which honestly is what people have asked us to do.
Good to hear that regular membership will not differ from lifetime. That makes it easier to compare the Lifetime fee against the monthly/yearly ones.
However, still confused about that 'core features' thing. In the past, the top tier of Sonar always came with extra goodies, and future releases always came with newer goodies. E.g. my X1 came with Dimension Pro, True Pianos,... which I didn't have with my older versions of Sonar (8 or the pre-Sonar releases). Upgrading from X1 to Platinum now gave me ProChannel stuff (Breverb, Tape Emu...), Melodyne... The examples you give are not relevant since they were always stand-alone releases never included. Actually they are relevant, because X1 also came with Z3TA+ 1.5 which I then could upgrade to 2 at a discount.
If the regular membership will never have any of these new goodies anymore, we are clearly getting less for our money, unless the regular membership gets cheaper. $149 a year for Platinum just purely for new features and fixes would definitely be a step down from what we got with upgrades before Platinum or the membership during Platinum. Just looking at the Update history for SPlat until now, I see several additions thrown in after the Platinum launch that I would consider goodies and not core features: TH3, Rapture Session, EDM Percussion Loops, Drum Replacer, etc.... If all of that stops happening in the future, then I would hope that the membership fee is lowered significantly.