Geoff Cattle
... X3 is still working, I just don't know about how future Win 10 updates might screw it.
...
It's worth thinking about what Microsoft can change that will mess thing up. At the application layer the answer is probably not a lot which is why there are so many old software products still running on Windows 10 today with few or no problems.
At the hardware/driver level the probability gets higher which is why we experience problems with hardware devices needing some attention after a Windows update. The challenge here could be if they stop working altogether you need to find something that is compatible with the latest version of Windows 10 and X3. But then I doubt that many devices explicitly support X3 now they'll just support one of the standards that X3 supports like ASIO.
Problems might also occur where the layers cross over. Kinetic, for example, hangs if any new VSTs have been installed and needs to be "Run as Administrator" to clear the issue. After that it runs great until the next VST is installed.
Sonar's single platform approach and their adoption and support of Microsoft technologies probably means that the various versions are more likely to keep running than most of the cross platform competitors.
Of course it makes sense to prepare for the possibility of a failure but in doing this it is really important that you also figure out how to determine what has failed because no one wants to buy a new DAW when all they needed to do was "Run as Administrator" or they really needed a new Audio Interface and still have to buy one for the new DAW.
If you've trusted X3 this far on Windows 10 nothing has really changed and you have been successfully managing these risks.
Actually one thing has changed, if it is X3 that is broken you'll need to decide who to give your cash to for a new DAW because an upgrade to the latest Sonar is no longer an option.
My personal guess, taking all of this into consideration, is that your copy of X3 will run just as long as my Sonar Platinum 2017.10. Some might even hypothesise that because its been stable longer it might even last longer.
In spite of the doom and gloom about this I think the consensus is that Sonar will work for a long time if tha's your preferred option and those who are switching are doing so for one of two reasons.
- They run studios to generate an income so need the extra security that software support brings. Imagine saying to a paying customer "we'll be recording today with Sonar, you might have read about Gibson pilling the plug on it".
- Making a change makes sense because its either the right time or they had been secretly considering it for a while and the Gibson announcement gave them a good excuse. (OK the second one may be a bit harsh because no one here suffers from GAS)
I chose to switch now because it seemed like a good time and I also have some older hardware that I've been thinking about replacing as well. Good news for me is that l have got all my old stuff working with Cubase, bad news is that I'm reading manuals a bit more than usual.
I'm also still using Sonar and have no plans to uninstall it.