Re:Vocals Mic Recommendations
2012/03/20 10:30:47
Last night I did a recording session with a female vocalist. I used my SM-58 and my Rode NT-2A to track 5 takes of a new lead vocal.
We started tracking with the Rode NT-2A .....recording 3 tracks
Then, for grins, I decided to record 2 more tracks using the 35 year old SM-58 I had laying around.
I used a pop filter on all the takes.
There is a definite difference, as I would have expected between these two mics. The Rode was louder, and had a more present, intimate sound quality as well as better (cleaner) lows and sparkling highs. I was recording with the gain set about 5 or 6 on the input to the interface channel.
The 58 needed the gain cranked a bit to get a robust wave in the track. Somewhere around 7 or 8, I would guess. The wave was nice and robust as well. Proximity played a much larger role in the sound of the 58. After a few takes, we recorded 2 tracks with her singing right up on the pop filter and the mic sans windscreen about 1" behind the pop filter. A few takes without the pop filter showed we needed the filter. At first, she pulled back 6" to 12" to belt out the chorus on the 58 like she did on the Rode, but loss of the proximity effect killed the quality of the track on the chorus. We retracked it with her "eating the mike" the entire take. Much better. Surprisingly, it did not overload the 58 doing that as I feared it might. She was strong and loud on the chorus.
The highs were rolled of a bit just from the natural sound of the mic. Nothing unpleasant, but a noticeable difference in tone and overall sound quality was evident between the 2 mics.
I actually did a trial playback with the 58 vox on lead with 2 of the Rode vox tracks panned opposite and way down, and it sounded pretty good.
Plans are to correct vocals and see what is what in those tracks today or tomorrow as I head toward the final mix.
You gotta remember, the 58 and it's companion the 57 are the industry standard work horse on stage for just about everything up there. It's not a bad mic and if it's the only one you have, you can't go wrong using it. Yeah, a nice condenser is better, and if you have one, use it. In a pinch, the 58 rocks.