RE: Another hardware vs. software thread
2006/08/17 15:24:28
(permalink)
The Modulation Matrix assignments allow to 'attach' a MIDI CC to a given parameter so it works *in parallel* to the value you set in the knob. This is how DP and RP allow polyphonic modulations, and gives you an enormous assignment power.
For instance, using the Modulation Matrix you could attach the incoming MIDI note-on velocity value to filter cutoff. Then, if you play a chord, every note would get its own cutoff value, which would depend on the velocity of each particular note in the chord. On top of that, you could set a couple of MIDI controls, etc.
Each row in the Modulation Matrix gives you a new option to add a new modulation link. You could have multiple MIDI controls, modifying the same parameter (i.e. Cutoff), with different depths, and what's more interesting for this topic, different smooth values. If you reverse-engineer some DP and RP patches, you'll see that smooth values are not only used to 'hide' the stepping, but also with creative, motion-generating goals.
What you enter in the Modulation Matrix is valid for that particular patch. This allows you to create completely different setups for a pad, than for a lead, for instance. MIDI Learn, OTOH, is global: its goal is to 'adapt' your set of MIDI controllers to particular controls which you want to keep doing the same function in all patches and instances.
MIDI Learn is also many-to-many: you can have multiple MIDI Controls controlling the same parameter, and a single MIDI Control controlling multiple parameters. MIDI Learn doesn't have smoothing itself, and while it's theoretically possible to implement it would be rather limited when compared with the Modulation Matrix approach, considering the interaction between automation and MIDI Learn both fighting for same knob control.
We all know that the Modulation Matrix is an arcane, obscure terrain, while MIDI Learn is Disney fun. However, power needs to be somewhere: I do recommend everyone to dive a bit on it. The possibilities are enormous.
-René