Catanya New Issue - Access Violation Error

Decided to put this on its own thread in order to keep it specific and not get dragged into other discussions.
 
I have a project called "Catanya Crash Project"  All I had to do previously was open the project and hit space bar and my PC cratered hard.  It has 3 instances of Catanya triggering Rapture, Dim Pro and RGC.  The project also has Jamstix playing a beat.
 
I opened it up hit space bar on a 16 bar loop and have been playing with it non-stop for 30 minutes.  Not even a hiccup.  Changed sequence patterns on the fly, changed synth patches, opened and closed multi-dock....Beeeyouteefull.
 
I then added a single separate midi track and changed the input to Catanya-1, Catanya-2 and Catanya-3.  Each time when I hit record, Sonar only recorded the midi produced by the appropriate Catanya Arp instance.
 
I then added 3 midi tracks and made each record catanya 1, 2 and 3 simultaneously and it worked perfectly.
 
I have seen grumblings about other arps and synths, but I can say that so far, IMHO, when it concerns Catanya, x-talk and crash seems to be fixed in X3d.
 
Thank you bakers.

Actually, here is an even better test:
 
Using your original configuration with 3 Catanya instances and having the inputs selected for the individual MIDI channels like you did originally, add another MIDI track and configure it to record from an external MIDI keyboard. Start recording from the MIDI keyboard. Make sure to play some of the same note values as what the Catanya plugins are sending out. Hold the keys on the keyboard down for a bar or two to make sure you will notice any cut off notes.
 
Does it still cut off MIDI notes recorded from the external MIDI keyboard?

Just tried it a few times....midi keyboard on 4th midi track does not show up on any other midi recorded channel.
 
Nor does it cut off or overwrite any of the ARP notes coming from Catanya on other midi channels.
 
Looking good !!  Signal independence seems to be working !!

On this post I have bought Catanya Arp and dare i say so far all good -Awesome .:) 

Not sure I follow...
 
Are you trying to trigger Sylenth, (the 4th synth), from one of the three Catanya instances mentioned, or a 4th instance of catanya ?
 
JR

if it was my project i would add sylenth and true pianos as virtual instrument tracks and make sure the midi input is your keyboard and not midi-omni or Catanya.
 
As long as the input to these virtual istrument tracks is none or keyboard, than Catanya should not trigger them. 
 
I use virtual instrument tracks whenever possible so as to not lose track of which midi track is triggering which synth.

So Foster - All working for you now? Keep us updated... Cheers...

Wow!  I'm not sure if I should laugh or cry.  We first encountered the multiple MIDI sequencers bug with Catanya on 8-22-2009 and reported it then.  I'm delighted to hear it's fixed, but...
 
I would love to hear a layman's version of how the issue was ultimately resolved.  Given all the heat it generated many of us speculated that it must be so deeply integral to Sonar's code that nothing short of a complete rewrite would reach it.  Glad to hear we were wrong!

Noel Borthwick [Cakewalk]
No the issues were relatively straightforward but required some time and testing to identify the issues troubleshoot and test. 
One was a MIDI routing/echo issue and the other was a multithreading issue. 

 
Not to be petulant, but FOUR years of testing and troubleshooting?  And this fix could not have been made in X2 or X3 on initial release?  I gotta admit, this was one issue that really bugged me too.  Well, whatever is motivating you guys to get at these long term bugs and point releases is a good thing, I guess.

 
This is great news.  I'm now eyeing Catanya for myself...
 
 

can anyone confirm this fixed with kirnu cream? tia

thanks for replying, it's not mfx, the midi fx version is a lpx thing, see http://www.kvraudio.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=394138

well I'm not at the box x1d is on right now, and your sig doesn't show on my phone, but it's a q6600/8g/win7x64/3HDs the audio interface is a esi wavetrrminal 192m hw wise, solid workhorse, software being all the usual stuff, music only, all updated, blah

noone's using kirnu cream?

hi alex, it's not relevant to this, i'll provide the specs if necessary :)
i will add that i do appreciate your efforts in sorting out the forum rabble, good work sir :)
maybe someone with specs could try the demo?