My only comment, at the risk of losing my status as "thePianist," is that I use True Pianos Amber and find it very pleasing and musical. I have tried PianoTek demo and agree it's superior, but everyone's ears are different, and familiarity is a big part of what we like or dislike. I actually sold Steinway Pianos for a few years in the late 90's and having ;played a ton of them, they can sound radically different from each other, being hand-crafted items rather than mass produced pianos. And the DSF Steinway doesn't seem to have the "body" it deserves--some notes just seem clunky to me. At least the Amber Piano is consistent, if not spectacular. And the price is right, heh heh.
I'd love to hear the critique of True Piano Amber by the folks in this thread, as I am shopping for yet another Piano VST, and right now I'm leaning toward's Ivory II Grand, or PianoTeq. And, BTW, I was on Garritan's site, and I think his "Approved" Steinway VST is no where to be found anymore.
Thanks for an interesting thread, folks.

@ thePianist You should download the Atlantis TruePiano module it is free and try it. It has become my goto piano.

Cliff:

For accuracy compared to a real grand piano action feel, I'm partial to keyboard controllers that use Fatar keyboard modules.  Studiologic is Fatar's brand but I believe other manufacturers may use Fatar keyboard modules in their products.

I learned about Fatar through learning about my "classic" Alesis QS8, which is based on an older Fatar keyboard module.  (My QS8 is 15 years old.)  When the Alesis QS7s and QS8s came out, the keyboard action on them was heralded as the best for the money.  As an example, on my QS8, I can actually feel the hammer's little "kick" as it hits the string, even at low velocity.  (Of course, there is no string, but their action simulates this.)

Here's a link to one of the Fatar's current SL-Series controllers: SL 990 Pro

You should check them out if you can,
Paul