Keith Albright [Cakewalk]
It's on so if you open an automation lane and draw in a change you'll hear it. If it weren't enabled by default you wouldn't hear any change.
True. However, I find the current implementation (R button already enabled when the track is created) not helpful in my situation. I mean, how can you EASILY tell which tracks have written automation data in them and which tracks don't if ALL tracks' R buttons are enabled (lit in blue)?
http://forum.cakewalk.com/Automation-Read-button-grayed-until-you-actually-entered-any-automation-m3226256.aspx Of course, the Automation Lanes button on the track looks blue-ish when there is an automation lane or lanes in the track, but the buttons are not visible when the tracks are minimized (or when working in CV), and also automation envelopes can be created without creating any automation lane (yes, by using Edit Filter).
For this reason, all Automation Read buttons in my custom project template are disabled by default. I think that automatable parameters should be automatically read-enabled
only when the user created the automation lane or selected the desired automation parameter from the Edit Filter drop-down. I even suggest that no automation data (even if invisible) should exist in the track until the user creates it himself. You'll see what I mean by following these steps:
1. Insert an audio track.
2. Click the R button in the track to disable automation read.
3. Click the Automation Lanes button to create an automation lane (Volume).
4. Click the Add Automation Lane button to add a lane (Pan).
5. Click the two R buttons in the lanes to enable automation.
Notice that the R button in the
track header is only half lit. This means that some automation parameter or parameters exist in the track
although the user didn't create them himself. I think new users will find this behavior confusing.
And I still strongly wish for a
customizable MSR module in the narrow track strip in CV. I really want to replace the Arm and Input Echo buttons with Automation Read and Phase buttons.