• SONAR
  • Remember the bug where the lowest note on the staff couldn't be edited?
2014/06/20 10:48:29
polarbear
The one where you can't right click the lowest note on any given track in staff view to get its Note Properties page, but they fixed it in X3e? Well the bug seems to have come back again out of nowhere for me. Any one else having this problem? In most cases you can draw a note underneath it, then go right click the note you were trying to change, make your changes, and then delete the lower note you drew in... But that's a major pain and it doesn't seem to be working on this one track (I'm not allowed to draw a note lower for some reason).
2014/06/20 11:24:18
Splat
Is this an old project?
2014/06/20 12:03:16
icontakt
This is still present in X3e. I contacted tech support after the previous thread but was told it's unreproducible. I was very busy around that time so I couldn't reply to them (they were also busy relocating the office), but after seeing this thread now I replied to them with the link to the previous thread.
2014/06/20 12:30:17
polarbear
New Project.
 
And yea it seemed to have gone away I thought with X3e, but yea, it's back. So annoying.
2014/06/20 12:43:03
Wookiee
Still about but tends to be unpredictable as to when it might happen.
2014/06/20 13:35:15
Splat
Let us know the issue number thanka. Sorry Takuji I forgot to document that other issue I could not repro, I'll try again and I'll do it so soon.
2014/06/20 13:41:36
Sidroe
I have always had this occurrence. And , yes, I'm running X3e. Sometimes it works and sometimes not. I found for a time you had to click in a strategic area of the note head. Most of the time, that doesn't even work anymore.
2014/06/20 14:15:16
polarbear
Yea I haven't like, rebooted or anything since it's turned back up (it just started happening again after months and months last night). But hopefully it goes away on my next reboot. 
2014/06/20 21:21:01
icontakt
CakeAlexS
Let us know the issue number thanka. 

 
The Problem Reporter ticket closed as unreproducible ("Contact Tech Support" to be more precise) is CWBRN-23709.

The case I'm currently dealing with tech support is Case 128412. I received a reply several hours ago saying they can't still reproduce it, so I've replied to them with a video clearly showing the issue attached.
 
Below are the steps to reproduce the issue (reproducible at least on my end):
 
1. Create a new project using the Normal project template.
2. Insert a MIDI track and hit Alt+3 to open the Piano Roll view.
3. Using whatever method you like (I used the Smart tool), enter/record note events on C5 and D5, like this:

4. Hit Alt+6 to open the Staff view.
5. Select the Smart tool in the Control Bar and right-click each note to open the Note Properties dialog box.
 
[Expected Results]
All notes open the Note Properties dialog box when right-clicked.
 
[Actual Results]
All C5 notes show a right-click menu when right-clicked, like this:

2014/06/23 00:22:33
skitch_84
I used to work almost exclusively in staff view when composing. This happened to me all the time. My work around was to place another note on the staff, adjust that note's velocity/length/etc., then delete the note I couldn't edit and move the new note down. This seemed to occur when I reached the very bottom extreme of the ledger lines.
12
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account