Bub
In all seriousness ... what did Mike do that was wrong? Yeah, his post was a bit of a zinger and probably could have been worded a little different, but for the most part I think he's pretty much dead on. My LOL was the 'holy crap I can't believe you just said that' kind.
And let's be honest here ... there's hardly a person in this thread who has any room to be criticizing others for their behavior ... some admin included.
Hey Bub, I don't think it's what anyone did that was wrong....personally, if you don't mind my take, I felt (not singling anyone out...just the over-all vibe I got from some of the responses) I felt a few people may have taken things a bit out of context to what they were really meant to be. For example, let's say you worked for Cakewalk. I know you're pretty much a hobby guy with recording etc, but to me you're a serious hobby guy that does a really good job on your stuff.
That said, if you were having issues with low end in your mixes and one day bought a sub and it allowed you not to second guess yourself anymore in the low end area and you just felt like sharing that in a blog because Cake said it was ok to, would you be a little upset if people jumped all over you for stating your opinion on what has worked for you? Regardless of how some of the facts pro engineers would figure into the equasion may not be there, would your opinion be any less credible?
See I look at it this way. The super pro guy on here pretty much are etched in stone with how they think, what they do and where their experience level may be. There are also more people that probably aren't super pro on this forum that could really benefit from having a sub if they are struggling to hear bass in their mixes. See man, I was one of those guys. LOL! Bass was something that plagued me for so many years, I wasted too much time.
Yeah, monitor/room tuning was one of my major flaws...but without it, just adding that sub made an incredible difference for me. Can you see my point at all? And, since this is the hottest part of the forum, why not tell the people on here that could benefit from this that may not be pro's that just may be in need of fixing a low end issue? That's how I took the blog. Just a normal man that happens to work for Cakewalk sharing what has worked for him in the event others may have been having that issue.
I don't think any of it was really misleading as I have heard systems in rooms that didn't have any room or monitor tuning that just did well with the addition of a sub. As a matter of fact, I just worked in a room last week that was like that. The guy had a nice set of Dynaudio monitors and he just bought a sub. He had the sub dialed in a bit subby sounding which I picked up on as soon as I listened to my reference material....but finding the sweet spot for that sub took 15 seconds and other than some foam and stuff, this guy really didn't have much in the way of tuning or anything. The mix I did there came out wonderful and I didn't even use ARC or anything else.
So in certain situations, the addtion of a sub can really make a nice difference without all the pro stuff that goes with it. It's just a basic statement of "hey, this worked for me...it may work for you too" is how I took it. I wasn't thinking about Mike T being a pro engineer or anything...or that it should be a spot on, loaded with tech facts blog for pro's because Cakewalk is a professional company or anything. I just took it as "that's what worked for him and he shared it." I'd be willing to bet that's how Mike T felt about it too, ya know? Does this make any sense at all? Honest, I'm not trying to make any waves or upset anyone....I just felt that a few may have been reading into it a bit too deep even though some of their pro assessments would be correct. If it were someone from here that was just a normal dude that didn't work for the company, would that person receive the same comments?
Just curious....you get good results with your mixes....do you use a sub? If not, a guy like you with your set-up doesn't appear to need one. If you DO use one, how would you fair if you mixed without turning it on? I'd fail miserably without mine. LOL!
-Danny