Just terrific, guys.  First class all the way and an inspiration.  So much talent here!

Herb... I hear the mandolin... but I'm certain I hear an acoustic guitar being strummed as well....  Am I wrong?  That's the jangly instrument I was referring to.

Herb says I did 3, it's 1 part, but 3 tracks (true mid side recording) My James Goodall;

Very nice arrangement.  Nice arrangement on the acoustics.  What a difference an arrangment makes.  Well done too.

Daryl

You trust me... The equipment shown may be out of the reach of some/most. But the same techniques may be used w/other equipment/pre-amps. It's good stuff. But more importantly, Herb's mix rocks. And He and Scotty's performances (especially Scotty's performance, no disrespect Herb) I was lucky enough to collaborate with Professionals... I'm "OK" at a bunch of different things? And pretty good at others :-) It's a true joy when you can work with others whom you truly respect and admire... I give thanks for that opportunity. And in particular, for my colab partner not reflected here, Mr. Markno999, He is the man! Scotty is the man! Herb is the man!

There are many people here who are exceptionally talented... I am blessed to have the opportunity to work with some of them. P.S., please don't pay attention to things I post after a certain hour? I look at some of the things I say the next day and say, really? Really? What a jerk! And then I realize "it was me." It's Mister Hyde, pay no attention to him. Dr. Jeckle's not so bad...

Dr. Jeckle's not such a bad guy, he gets a bad rep from Mr. Hyde....

Nice Herb , sort has a late night in the bar jukebox sound to it . I mean that in a good way , I enjoyed the song and the mix in this tune of yours .

Good job -James

Daryl.... I've learned a few things in 3.5 years....

Tony.... I like it too

James.... thank you sir


Scotty:  uhhhhhh I dunno..... ?  All I've ever had was one track...I was thinking you mixed them and sent it as one track.... if you sent 3 on the original project.... it musta been Robby who conflagerated them into one.  Unless I'm missing the jist of your post totally...which is also possible.  

I think you did..... 

and you did a fine job on the premixing.... just like a certain vocal track more recently.... stay tuned..... it's almost time. I'll be discussing that with someone up the food chain in Nashville next week. 

Alegria

"Janet"

Alegria is the one who put them all up on his website. Not sure if they're still there.

Hey Janet, it's been awhile and, of course they're still there. The only reason I would remove them is if I was asked to do so by the original author(s).

And here is the post for the project, which contains a link to the complete presentation.

"Missing Person" presentation... Happy New Year all!

To this day, this is the nicest and most interesting project I've seen coming out of the "Songs" forum for many reasons, IMHO. And I still listen to all songs in sequence once in a while. It would be nice to see a similar project take shape again, not as a competition but rather a challenge to put into practice all that we have learned over the years. Again, kudos to all participants for a job very well done indeed! 

Hi JC... nice to hear from you again here at the forum...

  Not to sound redundant but this is great> I think you guys all did a nice job on it.

yes
nice and solid arrangement, and all the playing is just perfect.
really nice lyric, and so plaintively delivered in the song, just really nice.
the violins set it off nicely.

My opinion of how a violin differs from a fiddle;

A violin plays notes from a sheet of paper, whereas a fiddle plays from the heart.

You guys made a great song. Very authentic and genuine. Well done all the way around. Thanks for sharing.